1. THE ERROR WE ALL SEE
Let us imagine a familiar situation during a match. A midfielder receives the ball with their back to goal, tries to turn and loses possession under pressure from an opponent.
From the touchline, the coach reacts immediately: “You should have played it first time!” “You can’t give the ball away there!” or “You need to look before you receive it!”
The loss of possession is clear, and the correction may seem reasonable. But have we really understood why the player lost the ball?
Perhaps they did not scan before receiving, misread the situation, or failed to execute the solution they had chosen. It is also possible that their teammates’ positions and movements limited the options available to them.
The error is visible, but the reasons behind it are not always so obvious.
This is our first challenge as coaches: not to focus solely on what the player has done, but to investigate what happened and why.
2. THE PLAYER DOES NOT MAKE DECISIONS IN ISOLATION
In football, a player’s options for action are constantly shaped and reshaped by their relationships with teammates and opponents.
A run can create a passing lane, a movement can open up space, and a coordinated action can create an advantage. In the same way, pressure from the opposition can reduce the time available to make a decision, close down options, or make it harder to keep the game flowing.
These relationships are not simply the setting in which the player makes decisions. They are part of the problem they need to read and solve.
That is why, when we analyse an individual performance, it is not enough to watch the player at the centre of the action. We need to understand what options the team was creating, how the opponents were involved, and how these relationships shaped the alternatives available to the player.
The environment does not determine the player’s decision, but it shapes the options for action they encounter in each situation.
However, having these options available does not necessarily mean being able to identify, interpret, and make use of them.
3. WHAT OPTIONS COULD THE PLAYER RECOGNISE AND MAKE USE OF?
When analysing a decision, we need to consider one fundamental difference: the coach is interpreting a situation that has already happened, whereas the player had to deal with it in real time, without knowing how it would unfold.
From the touchline, we have a different perspective and, when we use video, we can pause the footage, replay a sequence, and identify options that may not have been obvious during the action.
Imagine that, when reviewing a loss of possession, we discover that a teammate was free on the other side of the pitch. The solution seems simple: switch play. But could the player really recognise that option? Did they have time to scan? Did they have the necessary resources to play the pass?
This example allows us to distinguish three fundamental elements involved in solving a situation:
ENVIRONMENT → RECOGNITION OF OPTIONS → ABILITY TO MAKE USE OF THEM
The environment creates options for action through the positions, movements and relationships between teammates and opponents. Recognising these options depends on the player’s individual ability to scan, identify and interpret relevant information. Being able to make use of them involves selecting a solution and having the necessary resources to attempt to carry it out under the conditions presented by the game.
A team may create numerous advantages that its players are unable to recognise or make use of. Equally, a player may have excellent scanning, interpretation and execution skills, yet find themselves in a context that offers very few opportunities to use them.
Individual performance emerges from the interaction between the options offered by the environment and the player’s ability to recognise and use them.
This perspective raises a fundamental question for talent assessment: the performance we observe in a player depends not only on their abilities, but also on the opportunities the game offers them to demonstrate those abilities.
That is why, when assessing footballers, identifying talent or designing learning experiences, we need to consider both individual abilities and the conditions in which they can be expressed.
This way of understanding performance also means we need to be cautious when assessing individual decisions. A reasonable decision can result in a loss of possession, just as a poor decision can end successfully.
The outcome of an action tells us about its consequences, but it does not, in itself, explain the quality of the decision that came before it.
4. A DIFFERENT INTERPRETATION, A DIFFERENT APPROACH TO TRAINING
If individual performance depends on the interaction between the environment and the player’s abilities, our interventions need to address the nature of the difficulties we identify.
When the team does not create enough options, we need to design experiences that improve collective relationships: supporting angles, runs to receive the ball, use of space and coordination between players.
When options are available, but the player is unable to recognise them, we need to design experiences that stimulate scanning, attention, interpretation and anticipation, encouraging decisions that are increasingly well suited to the demands of the game.
When the player recognises a solution but does not have the necessary resources to make use of it, we need to develop their execution skills in situations that reproduce the demands of the game.
However, these difficulties do not necessarily occur in isolation. Collective relationships, perception, interpretation, decision-making and execution all interact within the same situation.
We can analyse difficulties separately in order to understand them, but we need to design experiences that respect the interactions taking place during the game.
This means designing systemic learning experiences in which all these elements interact simultaneously, reproducing the relationships and demands of the game. Within these experiences, we can prioritise specific learning objectives without isolating them from the other abilities involved in solving a situation.
In this way, the aim is not simply to correct what the player has done, but to transform what the team can create, what the player can recognise, and what they are able to solve.
The same error can lead us to completely different training approaches. The difference lies in how we understand the problem that caused it.
5. CHANGING OUR PERSPECTIVE
The way we observe the game shapes what we interpret and the decisions we make as coaches. That is why analysis requires us to question our initial conclusions, listen to the player, and recognise that the same action may have different explanations.
When we attribute a difficulty solely to the player, we may try to change their behaviour without changing the conditions that are limiting them. But we can also make the opposite mistake: attributing all their difficulties to the context and failing to develop the individual abilities they need to deal with increasingly complex situations.
Our responsibility is to understand how both elements interact and what we can do to support learning.
The aim is not to justify errors or find someone to blame, but to interpret individual performances rigorously, recognising both the player’s abilities and the conditions in which they have to use them.
Not everyone who makes a mistake is the only one who contributed to causing it, nor are they necessarily the person who has the most to learn from that situation.
Perhaps the coach’s real challenge is not to identify who made the mistake, but to understand why it happened and what we need to change so that the player can find better solutions.
WHAT IF THE FIRST MISTAKE WE NEED TO REVIEW IS THE WAY WE INTERPRET THE GAME?
Eight questions a reader might ask
These questions are designed to explore the content of the article in greater depth and, in particular, to apply its methodological principles to the day-to-day reality of a coach.
No. Understanding the influence of the context does not mean removing individual responsibility.
The player still needs to observe, interpret, make decisions, and execute. However, their opportunities to act are conditioned by the relationships they establish with teammates and opponents.
Individual responsibility does not disappear; we need to interpret it within the conditions in which the action takes place.
The aim is not to justify mistakes, but to identify which factors we need to change in order to improve performance.
We cannot always tell by looking at the outcome alone.
A player may have recognised a passing lane and ruled it out because they anticipated an opponent’s intervention, because they considered another solution more advantageous, or because they did not trust themselves to execute the pass.
For this reason, the analysis must take into account the temporal and spatial conditions of the action, the information available, and the alternatives that existed.
It may also be useful to ask the player what they had observed and what they intended to do.
We must not confuse an option identified by the coach in the video with an option that the player actually recognised during the game.
Yes. This is one of the article’s key points.
A player may have excellent observation, interpretation, decision-making, and execution abilities, yet play in a team that creates few favourable opportunities for them to demonstrate those abilities.
The opposite can also happen: a highly favourable team context can facilitate a player’s performance and reduce some of the difficulties they have to solve.
This has important implications for player assessment and talent identification.
The performance we observe provides information about the player, but it does not necessarily represent the full extent of their abilities.
We must analyse the decision by considering the information available to the player, the options that existed, the demands of the situation and the foreseeable consequences of the different alternatives.
A decision may be reasonable yet end badly because of poor execution, an exceptional intervention by an opponent, or an event that was difficult to anticipate.
Likewise, a poor decision may produce a favourable outcome.
The outcome is important information, but it is not, in itself, an assessment of the quality of the decision.
The first step is to identify which factors appear to limit the resolution of certain situations most frequently.
We may find difficulties relating to collective relationships, the recognition of options, decision-making, or execution skills.
However, these elements interact and rarely occur in complete isolation.
For this reason, we must establish learning priorities without artificially separating the components of the game.
An activity may have the priority objective of improving observation, but it must allow the player to observe while interacting with teammates and opponents, making decisions and executing actions.
Yes. In fact, this is one of the article’s main methodological implications.
We can design an activity whose primary objective is to improve observation before receiving the ball.
To do this, we can modify the conditions of the game, the relationships between players, the spaces, or the available options, so that observing relevant information becomes particularly important when solving the situations.
However, the player will still need to interpret, make decisions, execute, and interact with their teammates and opponents.
Prioritising an objective does not mean separating it from the system of relationships that gives it meaning.
It has important implications.
If we assess a player solely on the basis of their visible performances, we may overrate footballers who play in highly favourable contexts and underrate others who have good abilities but find few opportunities to demonstrate them.
For this reason, as well as observing what a player manages to do, we should analyse the conditions in which they act, the options they recognise, the solutions they attempt, and how they respond when the demands of the game change.
Identifying talent requires us, as far as possible, to distinguish between what the context makes possible and what the player contributes to solving the situations.
The way we observe, interpret, and design training should change.
Rather than simply starting by asking what the player has done wrong, we should investigate what problem they had to solve, what options the environment offered, which ones they were able to recognise, and what resources they had to make use of.
Based on this interpretation, we need to design learning activities that integrate collective relationships, perception, decision-making and execution simultaneously, even if we prioritise specific objectives.
And we must maintain a critical attitude towards our own conclusions, because an initial explanation may be incomplete.
The real methodological change lies in moving away from designing training solely on the basis of observed mistakes and towards designing it on the basis of understanding the problems that cause them.























